Where Ingredients Find The Best Alternatives

Substitute For Goat Milk – Here’s Dairy & Non-Dairy Milk Alternatives

Substitute For Goat Milk
Substitute For Goat Milk

substitutesfor.com is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

People try to find out the best substitute for goat milk because they usually get short on it. The major reason behind this fact is the limited production and supply of goat milk.

Goat milk is a delicious addition to a number of cooking and baking recipes just because of its richer and creamier texture. It adds natural milk goodness to sweet dishes and makes them nutritiously healthy.

And having goat milk on hand means one can enjoy making caramel, cheese, mousse, buttermilk, and a variety of other baking products. But if you’re running short on goat milk, switch it with other closer alternatives and enjoy the moment.

Substitute For Goat Milk In Recipe

Most of the time, goat milk is used in different cooking and baking recipes to which it bestows delicious creaminess. In cooking dishes, its rich fat content gives smooth buttery sensations to the palate.

In baking dishes, goat milk softens the products, caramelizes sugar content, and ensures crack-free leavening. The fun fact is that you can replace it in both kinds of recipes. Interestingly, both dairy and non-dairy alternatives are out there to finish your recipes as intended.

So, opt for dairy substitutes if goat milk is unavailable anyhow to get a similar texture and flavor profile. However, if you’re allergic to goat milk or a lactose intolerant, go for non-dairy or vegan substitutes to meet your recipe preferences.

Dairy Substitutes

Dairy substitutes are closer candidates for replacing goat milk and are also readily available to make your food delectable. The most obvious replacements are cow milk and yogurt, however you can opt for other options too.

Cow Milk

Cow Milk
Cow Milk

Cow milk is the best and closest option to go with in place of goat milk. It has a similar texture, flavor, and nutrition with a bit thinner consistency. Cow milk is less thick and fatty than goat milk and hence is easily digestible.

Consider one cup of cow milk equals one cup of goat milk for preparing cooking dishes as well as baking items.

You may also Like:

Diastatic Malt Powder Substitute



The thicker smooth consistency of yogurt resembles goat milk greatly and thus works well in cooking dishes. Not only this, yogurt is also good to replace goat milk in baking to bring out soft and fluffy creations.

Consider ½ cup of yogurt equals 1 cup of goat milk to render the tartness of yogurt from making the final recipe flavor unappealing.

Non-dairy substitutes

Meet your health and taste preferences using a non-dairy and vegan substitute for goat milk if you’re allergic to goat’s milk or dislike its flavor.

Coconut milk

Coconut milk
Coconut milk

Coconut milk is non-dairy white milk essentially used in cooking and baking products to make them soft and fluffy. The natural coconut creaminess and consistency greatly resemble goat milk and also easily available all the time.

Consider one cup of coconut milk equals one cup of goat milk for baking and cooking dishes.

Cashew milk

Cashew milk
Cashew milk

Cashew milk is another non-dairy milk substitute mostly used in baking rather than cooking dishes. Its nutty creaminess and thick consistency resemble goat milk and similarly bestow food with the desired flavor.

Use 1:1 ratio to replace goat milk in making baked goods and sweet treats. One can also replace goat milk with cashew cream in baking goods.

Substitute For Goat Milk Powder

Goat milk powder is mildly sweet, digestible, nutritious, and brings fresh goat milk goodness to beverages and baking items. Interestingly, whole milk powder and cow milk powder do a similar job and therefore are good goat milk powder alternatives.

Whole milk powder is readily available, affordable, rich in nutrients, and is great for making delicious confections, smoothies, and fudges.

Similarly, cow milk powder replaces goat milk powder and adds a creamy goodness to baked goods. Swap the equal quantity of goat milk powder with the same quantity of whole milk or cow milk powder to make things better to taste.

Vegan Substitute For Goat Milk Cheese

Goat milk cheese is not a vegan-friendly product and thus never pops up in a vegan’s diet. So, one needs to replace it with any other ingredient to meet the diet specifications. If that’s a real problem, tofu would be the best alternative to go with.

Tofu will give you a variety of texture options with a closer goat cheese flavor. So, go for silken tofu or tofu cheese instead of goat cheese if craving a spreadable creamy sensation. And opt for firm tofu if want to replace the crumbly texture of goat cheese.

Another option is the homemade vegan goat cheese to satisfy your healthy diet plan. This way you can optimize the texture and flavor of the cheese according to your taste preferences.

Read also:

Gorgonzola Substitute


Can I Use Regular Milk Instead Of Goat Milk?

Regular milk could be a good replacement for goat milk in baking, desserts, and several other sweet treats. Most often, the regular whole milk is nothing but just the cow milk that’s rich in fat and protein.

Take a thought if you’re going to use regular milk in place of goat milk in cooking dishes. This is because regular milk is little runnier and less fatty than goat milk. So, it can ruin the texture of the dish entirely.

Can Lactose-Free Milk Substitute For Goat Milk?

In general, lactose intolerants can also consume goat milk because it’s quite lower in lactose sugar than regular cow milk. However, one can also swap goat milk with lactose-free milk to ensure better health.

Lactose-free milk is regular milk with added lactase to facilitate the digestion of lactose sugar. So, it’s safe to use it in your beloved recipes to caress the palate lusciously.

Is Goat Milk Similar To Cow Milk?

No, goat milk is not quite similar to cow milk as they both have a different texture and aftertaste. Goat milk is thicker, fattier, and creamier than cow milk and has a mildly sweet flavor with an earthy aftertaste.

The reason both are used alternatively in food recipes is their composition. Both goat and cow’s milk have protein, fats, and lactose to make dishes incredibly creamy and delectable.


Hey, I’m Ayesha Khalid, the main writer of Substitutesfor.com. I love to write about food ingredients, cooking guides, and helping tips and tricks to upgrade your cooking experience. The aim of writing is to provide you with a collection of substitutions and novel ideas to try so that you can find all the needed information at once. Here, you can get ideas according to your diet restrictions, taste preferences, and health conditions.

You May Also Like