Where Ingredients Find The Best Alternatives

Witch Hazel Substitute – What’s Good For Your Skin?

Witch Hazel Substitute
Witch Hazel Substitute

substitutesfor.com is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

Looking for the best witch hazel substitute is quite usual because it’s pretty hard to find this organic essence. And it’s a tired hassle to search for a witch hazel bottle while wandering from one aisle to the other.

Even online shopping stores and websites are running short on witch hazel for its limited supply. To more, getting access to the natural or organic brands of witch hazel is another great concern.

So, if you’ve tried all the possible ways to get witch hazel or don’t get it anywhere, we’ve something for you. Here is a whole list of alternative products that are similarly effective and beneficial as witch hazel. So, opt for any one to do things magically perfect.

Witch Hazel Substitute

Witch hazel has been a medicinal plant since long for treating skin-related problems. And even nowadays, several brands use witch hazel extract to make their skin toners, lotions, and ointments more potent, astringent, and effective.

Witch hazel is also a great soothing gel for preventing skin from itching after a bug or mosquito bite. Additionally, it works the best for reducing skin redness and rashes. So, if you have it on hand, you can use it as a face cleanser and even as an ointment to faint dark circles.

And if you have no witch hazel, don’t worry. Just explore the given list of replacements and choose your best.

  1. Slippery Elm for Witch Hazel Substitute

Slippery Elm for Witch Hazel Substitute
Slippery Elm for Witch Hazel Substitute

When witch hazel isn’t anymore to treat your skin, slippery elm can do the same job for you. It is the best sub for witch hazel you can use in various ways. Whether you’ve got a sore throat or any kind of inflammation, slippery elm will replace witch hazel entirely.

Buy on Amazon

To more, it has also great many topical benefits for a range of skin problems including redness, itching, rashes, and wounds. The best thing is that you can either apply it topically or ingest it with water or tea to get insane skin benefits.

Further Reading:

Substitute For Vegetable Oil In Pumpkin Bread

  1. Aloe Vera Replacement for Witch Hazel

Aloe Vera Replacement for Witch Hazel
Aloe Vera Replacement for Witch Hazel

Aloe vera is a natural soothing gel and is commonly used in a wide range of skincare products like witch hazel. And sometimes, you can even find a unique combination of these two amazingly effective natural products in one bottle.

Aloe vera is a commonly available witch hazel substitute in the market which you can also grow in your personal garden. It’s effective in treating or soothing skin burns and any kind of skin redness.

  1. Apple Cider Vinegar

Apple Cider Vinegar
Apple Cider Vinegar

It’s an ingredient everyone must carry in the kitchen pantry. Besides a culinary and cooking staple, apple cider vinegar is also the best replacement for witch hazel.

Check Price on Amazon

Similar to witch hazel, apple cider vinegar is great for removing dark circles, treating acne, preventing skin breakdown, and slowing skin aging. Being a natural product, you can either apply it topically or make any apple cider drink to get its ultimate health benefits.

  1. Peppermint Essential Oil

Peppermint Essential Oil
Peppermint Essential Oil

Peppermint oil is great for replacing witch hazel as a skin cleanser and toner. When thoroughly compared with witch hazel, peppermint essential oil has similar skin benefits.

Buy it on Amazon

It can heal skin wounds as an anti-inflammatory product, soothe sunburns, and make your skin feel fresh and glowing.

Read Also:

Substitutes For Vegetable Oil in Baking

  1. Use Lavender Oil instead Witch Hazel

Use Lavender Oil instead Witch Hazel
Use Lavender Oil instead Witch Hazel

As a unique substitute for witch hazel, lavender oil is special in its own way. Besides treating all skin-related issues, lavender oil is a great wound healer owing to its anti-bacterial and anti-microbial properties.

Buy on Amazon

You can also use it as an astringent spray in your rooms and kitchen to keep bugs away. So, manipulate your substitution in your own way and get benefited in multiple ways.

  1. Try Rose Water for Witch Hazel Replacement

Rose Water

Rose water as a witch hazel alternative is a great skin freshener and toner. It keeps your skin oil-free and may prevent sunburn. Apply it topically with a cotton swab and wash it off after 10 to 20 minutes.

Check Price on Amazon

Rose water is not a good replacement to go for if you’re looking for witch hazel for treating skin burns or wounds.

  1. Cucumber Juice

Cucumber Juice
Cucumber Juice

Cucumber juice is a whole package of skin-caring ingredients and is also commonly used in various skin DIY’s. To more, it’s a natural and healthy sub for witch hazel you can either apply topically or make refreshing cucumber drinks.

Buy on Amazon

Instead of witch hazel, use cucumber juice to reduce wrinkles, eye puffiness, dark circles, and fine lines.

Homemade Witch Hazel Substitute

Rather than trying any skin care product, make your own witch hazel if you have witch hazel bark on hand. Yes, it’s a really simple and quick recipe to prepare a great substitute that is pure, potent, and natural.

What you have to do is heat the pan containing 5 cups of distilled water and 5 ounces of witch hazel bark at a very very low flame. Don’t allow the water to simmer or boil at any stage.

You may also like:

Substitute For Baking Soda In Caramel Corn

After heating for one to two hours, strain the water in a pot and also squeeze the witch hazel bark to take the organic essence out properly. When water attains room temperature, add a cup of vodka in it and mix properly.

So, your organic witch hazel is ready to go. Cool it and store it in a dry place away from the direct sun rays.

Now, you have a better understanding of how to replace witch hazel with other organic products depending on for which purpose you’re seeking witch hazel.


Hey, I’m Ayesha Khalid, the main writer of Substitutesfor.com. I love to write about food ingredients, cooking guides, and helping tips and tricks to upgrade your cooking experience. The aim of writing is to provide you with a collection of substitutions and novel ideas to try so that you can find all the needed information at once. Here, you can get ideas according to your diet restrictions, taste preferences, and health conditions.

You May Also Like