Where Ingredients Find The Best Alternatives

Substitute For Shiitake Mushrooms – Here’s 15 Top Ideas to Try

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on whatsapp
Substitutes For Shiitake Mushrooms
Substitutes For Shiitake Mushrooms

substitutesfor.com is reader-supported. When you buy via links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

Is there any substitute for shiitake mushrooms? Can you replace them in your favorite recipe calls for shiitake mushrooms? Go ahead to know what really means for your incredible cooking experience with mushrooms.

Shiitake mushrooms need no introduction as they are pretty common all over the world for their soft, velvety, and meaty texture. They are rich in savory, juicy but little bit chewy and earthy flavor that easily replaces meat in several traditional cuisines.

Adding shiitake mushrooms to routine-based diet is great fun as it gives grounding depth to food. But what if you have no access to shiitake mushrooms for any reason? Since they have a unique flavor profile, sometimes it’s got much tricky to replace shiitake mushrooms, but you can try.

Here, know the best substitutes for shiitake mushrooms to get a similar meaty goodness. However, it’s very important to decide which substitute will go best in your recipe instead of shiitake mushrooms. Once you know how to decide, you can easily replace them without compromising their flavor and texture. So, let’s read on and find out the best replacements for your food.

Substitute For Shiitake Mushrooms

Shiitake mushrooms being more common in traditional foods, are native to East Asia. They are widely cultivated and consumed nearby Asian territories. Both fresh and dried shiitake mushrooms are pretty common in meat dishes, soups, casseroles, and other versatile cuisines.

Nothing can be as flavorful and satisfying as much shiitake mushrooms. But you can use Dried Shiitake Mushrooms, Cremini Mushrooms, Oyster Mushrooms, Porcini Mushrooms, And Portobello Mushrooms instead of fresh shiitake mushrooms. So, let’s discuss them in detail.

Dried Shiitake Mushrooms


Dried shiitake mushrooms would be the best substitution when there’s no fresh shiitake on hand. Although both fresh and dried versions are the same thing but later has a stronger aroma and flavor.

Use dried or drained shiitake mushrooms with a lighter brown umbrella or cap and a nice luster. There are three typical kinds of dried shiitake mushrooms, Donko, Kouko, and Koshin, depending on the appearance of the cap. All these are widely common in Chinese and Asian cooking dishes.

You can use any available type in your food recipe instead of fresh shiitake mushrooms. Make sure to pre-soak them before cooking as they will soon come back to life.

After soaking for 15 to 20 minutes, replace them with fresh shiitake mushrooms in Noodles, soups, stir-frying dishes, and in many more savory treats.

Cremini Mushrooms


Cremini is a smaller yet versatile mushroom with a smooth and round brown cap. Mostly, it is sold as Baby Bella mushrooms in the markets and superstores. Cremini resembles portobellos and white button mushrooms as they are the same variety.

Their juicy and savory flavor gives your dish all it needs. They offer a delicate, earthy, but meatier texture to your favorite food demanding for shiitake.

However, when compared with shiitake mushrooms, cremini has a little milder flavor. Therefore, use cremini as a substitute for shiitake mushrooms in salads, stews, sauces, and pasta.

Oyster Mushroom


Oyster mushrooms are the most common and probably the most delicious and flavorful variety of mushrooms. When compared to shiitake mushrooms, oysters are affordable and easily available in market stores throughout the year.

So, if shiitake mushrooms are little expensive to add to the shopping cart, buy oyster mushrooms instead of shiitake mushrooms. Oysters are edible fungi having shorter stems with oyster-like umbrellas.

In terms of flavor and texture, oyster mushrooms have a more delicate and chewy texture with complex hints of savory flavor. However, their taste is more creamy, sweet, and subtle seafood-like to many people.

Due to their deep pronounced, yet complex flavor, oyster mushrooms go great as shiitake mushrooms alternative in stir-fried food dishes, cuisines, stews, and meaty side dishes.

Porcini Mushrooms


Porcini mushrooms are also the best replacement for shiitake mushrooms in your favorite cooked treats. And similar to shiitake, porcini mushrooms are available both as fresh and dried in superstores.

So, if you’re going to make delicious pasta or risotto, go with the fresh version of porcini. However, they also go well in sauteed or fried side dishes. While, choose dried porcini mushrooms if you’re planning to prepare yummy stews, soups, and sauces.

In terms of flavor, porcinis have an intense meaty flavor profile. As a substitution for shiitake mushrooms, porcini gives umami, creamy, and rich flavor to savory treats. So, their final flavor is not too far from shiitake mushrooms when cooked.

Portobello Mushrooms


Portobello mushrooms are also the best substitutes for shiitake mushrooms. They are easily recognized for their rich, savory flavor and aroma with a meaty or chewy texture close to shiitake mushroom.

Portobellos are the mature version of cremini, offering more flavorful, meaty, and juicy texture to savory recipes. Because of their meaty caps, portobellos also substitute meat in several dishes.

And as the best replacement for shiitake mushrooms, portobellos go great in soups, stews, casseroles, and many other delicious savory treats.

Other Substitute For Shiitake Mushrooms

Oyster, cremini, portobello, porcini, and dried shiitake mushrooms are the best alternative for shiitake mushrooms. They offer almost similar flavor and texture to food as shiitake mushrooms if used wisely.

However, there are also some other substitutes that you can use instead of shiitake mushrooms in your recipes. Their final mouthfeel and texture aren’t too far from the real shiitake flavor. For instance, lobster, maitake, and enoki mushrooms would be the best substitutes for shiitake mushrooms. So, the final choice will be yours.

Lobster Mushrooms


Lobster mushrooms are known for their meaty, fishy, and seafood-like taste and flavor. They can be little bit chewy with a denser texture. Their subtle sweet flavor adds a lobster-like taste to savory dishes.

When compared with shiitake mushrooms, their flavor and texture profile slightly differ. However, you can still use them as a replacement for shiitake mushrooms in sauces, vegetable salads, roasted meat, and savory stews.

Maitake Mushrooms


Maitake mushrooms are well-known for their umami flavor and delicate texture. They have a pleasant yet stronger earthy aroma and are thus widely common in cooking recipes. Maitake mushrooms pair well with other traditional mushrooms.

They offer almost similar richness and filling to the dish like shiitake. Therefore, one can also use them as a substitute for shiitake mushrooms in sauces, stews, and salads.

They go great either boiled, fried, steamed, or grilled and as a savory side dish for meat, fish, and potato recipes.

Enoki Mushrooms


Enoki mushrooms are much like maitake mushrooms in flavor and texture. They offer a milder earthy flavor yet a stronger aroma to food dishes than maitake.

They retain their pleasant aroma, texture, and deep flavor profile even after cooking. Moreover, enoki mushrooms go well in dishes when they come to replace shiitake mushrooms. They go great in casseroles, pies, salads, meat, and poultry dishes.

Non-Mushroom Substitute For Shiitake Mushrooms

Here are some non-mushroom alternatives for shiitake mushrooms that will go great when there’s no mushroom on hand. Now, it’s the best part for vegans. Instead of shiitake, use other vegan replacements such as eggplant, bell peppers, zucchini, and celery to prepare vegetarian food.

Non-mushroom substitutes mean that there will be no mushroomy, woodsy, and seafood-like aroma and texture. Thereby, you can use them in your vegan recipes to achieve nearby flavor to shiitake.

If you’re going to prepare vegetable salad, stew, casserole, or stir-frying dish, use eggplant, zucchini, and celery as substitutes for shitake mushrooms. Moreover, if you have bell peppers and sun-dried tomatoes on hand, add them to your savory treat to achieve almost similar savory shiitake flavor.

Besides these substitutions, one also has an option to go with tempeh, tofu, and jack fruit to several pies, soups, sauces, and savory side condiments instead of shiitake mushrooms. So, don’t bound your cooking to some specific ingredients, be creative with your recipe flavors and mouthfeel.

How To Use Substitute for Shiitake Mushrooms?

As we all know, shiitake mushrooms have a unique texture and pronounced flavor. But there is a number of other mushroom and non-mushroom alternatives that you can use in place of shiitake. They will offer almost a similar flavor and sometimes texture to your dish as shiitake mushrooms.

So, when you want the similar shiitake texture or aroma in your food, go with portobello, cremini, porcini, and dried shiitake if possible. They offer a pleasant fungal-like aroma, chewy or fibrous texture with a subtle earthy flavor to the recipe calls for shiitake mushrooms.

But, if you have enoki, maitake, and lobster mushroom on your pantry, they will also go great as substitutions for shiitake.

However, if you are a vegetarian and want to get the mushroomy flavor in your dishes, you can use non-mushroom replacements such as eggplant, zucchini, celery, and tofu or tempeh. These alternatives will go well in stews, casseroles, salads, and pies.

Read also: Best Substitutes for Vanilla Bean Paste

FAQs About Shiitake Mushroom

How Long Are Shiitake Mushrooms Good to Keep?

Shiitake mushroom lasts fresh and good to consume for 10 to 14 days if refrigerated. Store them in a paper bag properly so that they can’t get any mold or bacterial growth on them. Dried shiitake mushrooms are best to store as they can be stored for up to months. If stored properly in the refrigerator, they will be good to keep for 6 to 9 months.

How Long Do the Shiitake Mushrooms Need To Be Cooked?

Shiitake mushrooms are quite easy and quick to make. They take almost 8 to 10 minutes to cook properly. It is not recommended to eat shiitake raw or undercooked, as they can harm you in many ways. So, cook them until they appear tender and golden brown with a pleasant earthy aroma, and that’s it.

How Can You Tell If a Porcini Has Gone Bad?

It’s not a tricky task to tell if porcini mushrooms go bad. If you find your porcini mushrooms slimy, you get your answer. Moreover, bad porcini has a foul or bad smell with off texture. Bad porcini mushrooms also have a bitter flavor. So, if you find any such sign in your porcini, discard them as they are of no use.

580cookie-checkSubstitute For Shiitake Mushrooms – Here’s 15 Top Ideas to Try


Hey, I’m Ayesha Khalid, the main writer of Substitutesfor.com. I love to write about food ingredients, cooking guides, and helping tips and tricks to upgrade your cooking experience. The aim of writing is to provide you with a collection of substitutions and novel ideas to try so that you can find all the needed information at once. Here, you can get ideas according to your diet restrictions, taste preferences, and health conditions.

You May Also Like